Sometimes people complain, “Why can this person win the lotto? Why can that person be the president/CEO? Why does that person have this abundance and I don't?”
Have you thought about whether you can really bear it when such abundance really falls upon you? Take the self-made millionaire vs the lotto-won millionaire; who is more likely to be capable of generating further growth in assets? We hear stories about lotto millionaires: not many seem to have happy endings. Take King Saul vs King David: Saul came to the throne without prior hardships, whereas David went through tremendous hardships before he reached his throne. One was focused on his own ego, deteriorated and gone loony, while the other was capable of repenting and learning through his mistakes. This cycle of humbleness and repentance built a much more solid foundation for capable leadership. If leadership is suddenly thrust upon you when you are still unprepared to take on leadership, how long can you last?
For you, God, tested us; you refined us like silver. You brought us into prison and laid burdens on our backs. You let people ride over our heads; we went through fire and water, but you brought us to a place of abundance. (Psalms 66:10-12)
When we go through testing, refine like silver, we need to acknowledge the hand of God & the timing of God is in the midst of our trials. Joel Osteen shared in the Hillsong Conference 2013, “The winds that were meant to harm you; let God take control and take you to something more rewarding”. And on the contrary, sometimes what appears like an easy short cut may take you around in a bigger circle.
Hardship is the path to endurance and resilience if we maintain the right mentality in the process. Have you seen the toy “drumming monkey”?
http://youtu.be/lqDtAmX9ByM
http://youtu.be/VPxQuLVBwB0
We have many switches on us, and when other people accidentally strike upon the switches, we go off agitated and berserk like the “drumming monkey”. Hardship trains us so the numbers of switches decrease, and we become hard and shiny like diamonds.
Humbleness is also essential in the process. We cannot learn from people if we look down upon them. If we take a look around with humble eyes, we will then realize that God has in fact placed many good teachers around us. Diversity can create painful friction, but it also generates growth if we are willing to learn. We also need the courage to admit our own limitations and acknowledge that only God can help us through such mess.
Our God is a God of abundance. Are we ready to take on such abundance in our lives?
一個合神心意的領袖養成和培育是不容易的事。從我們現在的光景走到神為我們所預備的異象成就,中間這個塑造過程才是最難的。
神啊,你曾試驗我們,熬煉我們如熬煉銀子一樣。你使我們進入網羅,把重擔放在我們的身上。你使人坐車軋我們的頭,我們經過水火,你卻使我們到豐富之地。(詩篇66:10-12)
有些路看似捷徑,反而帶你繞過更大一圈。
Born in Taiwan but left when I was 8y.o., lived in 5 different countries by 18y.o., Christian, full-time General Practitioner in Eastwood! Loves travelling&adventures. Master of Divinity graduate. 台灣出生,八歲出國,十八歲時已經長期居住過五個國家,基督徒,道學碩士,在澳洲依士活作全職家醫科醫生,喜歡旅遊探險。
Monday, 22 July 2013
Sunday, 16 June 2013
王雙明生平(安息禮拜西元2013年六月十五日)
我的父親是一個勤奮好學、努力上進的人。他生於1952年,那是個普遍貧窮、物質極為匱乏的年代,小小年紀就警覺到要擺脫貧窮,唯有努力唸書,厚植實力,將來才有機會出人頭地,改善生活環境。所以他每天勤奮讀書,除了吃飯睡覺外,幾乎全部的精神都放在課業上,小學都拿第一名,初中時已讀到後腦杓長出白髮,所有升學考試都考上第一志願,親友都以他為榮。
為了減輕家庭的負擔和提早就業幫忙家計,父親放棄青少年夢想的第一學府建國中學,選擇台北工專。畢業後投入職場,從工程師、教師到公務員,兢兢業業,一邊辛勤工作,一邊仍不忘繼續努力讀書深造,後又考上台灣技術學院,完成大學學歷。
父親的妹妹回憶說,父親不善言辭,但很勇敢,姐妹弟弟被欺侮時他會挺身而出,為他們討回公道。在幼年的貧苦中過日子,養成克勤克儉的精神,生活平實自然,即使後來經濟條件大大改善了,依然節省成性,一生自奉甚儉,日常一身粗服,格外惜物愛物。
1980年認識了在當老師的母親林秀美,兩人都是一路考上第一志願的高材生。1981年與母親結婚,1983年在他30歲時我出生了。雖然父親不善於表達感情,但別人都看得出他對我的愛。小時候,爸爸是我最好的朋友,我覺得他對我很仁慈又有愛心,我時常跟他撒嬌,他常帶我去逛街,找不到他我就會很擔憂。
1986年母親考上外交部,1991年我8歲時母親外放,我隨她去美國及菲律賓,父親仍在中華電信工作,所以只能當空中飛人,飛來飛去。後來我到雪梨念醫學院,母親調到雪梨,父親退休也來雪梨,我們一家人終於團圓,感情更加親密,父親分擔許多家事,付出許多愛心。母親調回國後,他們在北投住了4年,買了有湯屋的大廈,常泡溫泉、爬山,母親說這是她一生最快樂安定的4年。今年母親派到愛爾蘭,父親又一路相隨照顧,在遙遠嚴寒的異國給母親最大的溫暖。如今他突然走了,母親失去最忠實的老伴,極為哀痛。
父親是一個內向的人,喜歡在家閱讀、聽音響、上網,學識非常淵博。他也喜歡騎著摩托車到處逛街,特別愛看電器產品。他很喜歡吃東西,但又不喜歡運動,所以30過後體重急速增加。母親很關心他的健康,最後在母親的鼓勵下勉強選擇爬山為他的運動,這幾年他們常去爬山。
他很念舊節儉,家裡堆了很多東西不肯丟,最後一台摩托車騎了14年都不換。但他對母親和我比對他自己好,好東西好吃的都留給我們。
父親身體狀況本來就不太好,膽固醇、血脂肪、血糖都高,加上抽菸,全都是冠心病的風險因素。今年5月25日他因心肌梗塞住院,我隔天就從澳洲趕回來。實際上他已胸悶一個禮拜,但怕家人擔心不講,還叫我不要回來,但看到我來看他還是快樂地笑了。5月27日裝支架後隔日轉到普通病房,心情很好。我順口問無神論的他對神有什麼看法,他說他相信宇宙有股不可抗拒的力量,說是神也好,他不認識祂,但這股力量已決定每個人的命運。5月29日他出院時我帶他去板城靈糧福音中心,並在黃聖堯牧師的帶領下做了決志禱告,對平時遠離教會的他極不尋常。隔天母親從愛爾蘭趕回來,平常不善於表達感情的他還高興地對母親誇獎我這幾天窩心體貼地照顧他,而且與主治醫師討論病情時很有醫生架式。
5月31日我回澳洲前父親與家人最後一頓牛肉麵午餐,胃口和平常一樣好,沒想到下午他就走了。爸爸走的很突然,是跟我媽媽在客廳時突然倒地當場過世。爸爸走時表情很安祥,沒有任何痛苦,甚至隔兩天去殯儀館看他時臉色是紅潤的,所以相信他已被接入主懷中。感謝神讓我在他的最後一個禮拜與他度過快樂時光,他血管打通、舒服自在的在家中過了兩天,也讓媽媽能跟他相處到最後一刻。
30歲真的是我和父親人生的轉捩點。父親30歲時,我出生了。在我30歲時,他去世了。(約12:24)說到「我實實在在的告訴你們,一粒麥子不落在地裡死了,仍舊是一粒,若是死了,就結出許多子粒來。」
最後我要告訴爸爸:「謝謝你給我和媽媽的愛,我們也很愛你。你走了,但你的愛永遠伴隨我們,我們會在天堂再團圓。」我也要感謝在場的各位親朋好友,特地來參加這安息禮拜,神必大大的祝福每一位。
Monday, 8 April 2013
Your Set of Cards 你手上的牌
Those that fail are those who are always finding excuses, whereas those who succeed are those who are always finding solutions!
Today, Pastor Steven Li did a short sharing with us during the 1503 Bread of Life Christian Church’s co-workers’ meeting:
Everyone is born with a different set of cards: Some received a very good set, being born in a rich family, talented, good looking and intelligent. Some received a very bad set, in poverty and handicapped.
However, the importance is not whether you get a good or bad set of cards, but how you play the cards on your hand!
How do we run our lives? How do we make use of our available resources?
And even if you were lucky and had an extremely good set of cards when you were born, it is nothing to get too arrogant about because it is not even to your own merit, since no one can choose what set of cards they are born with.
From the eternal perspective, life is like a play, with each of us playing different roles. We don’t have to rob others of their roles, or get into the role too deeply, as this will all pass eventually. We are responsible for playing our role to the best of our abilities, to equip us for what is eternal.
失敗的人永遠是找藉口,成功的人永遠是找解決方式!
今天李守博牧師在1503靈糧網絡同工會做了一個簡短分享,我覺得非常有收穫:
每個人出生所拿到的牌不同,有些人拿了一手好牌,出生在有錢的家庭,有才有貌又聰明,有些則是拿了一手爛牌,出生窮困,有殘疾。
但重點不在於你拿到的是否好牌,
而是你怎麼打你手上的牌!
我們是如何經營自己的生命呢? 我們是如何運用身邊的資源呢?
出生拿到好牌也沒什麼好自誇,因為也不是自己的功勞,人根本無法選擇自己出生所拿到的牌。
從基督徒的永恆觀裡來看,人生像是一場戲,我們每個人扮演不同的角色。不用去搶奪別人的角色,也不要入戲太深,因為這一切都會過去的。就好好的扮演自己所負責的獨特角色,為了要預備那永恆裡的生命。
Friday, 6 July 2012
自我形象。不同觀點。尊榮文化
一百塊的紙鈔,不管你怎麼踐踏,甚至丟到糞上,都是一百塊,價值不變。
人在神眼中的價值也是一樣的。神是每個然為寶貴。沒有誰比誰更寶貴,所以不需要一直用外來的東西來肯定自己的價值。也許有些人覺得自己長的美、有錢、頭腦好、社會地位高、等等,就視自己為[一千塊],而看別人為[十塊]。也有一些人自我形象低落,視自己為[十塊]。
但其實我們每個都是[一百塊]。假使你覺得你是[一千塊]而我是[十塊],我尊重你的想法,但我也很清楚的知道自己的價值,並不會因你認為我是[十塊]而覺得自己是[十塊]。每個人都有權利擁有自己的觀點,但是也要尊重別人的觀點,不要覺得每個人的觀點都一定要跟你一樣並強制性的試著轉化別人的觀點。
從馮志梅所主講的[如何愛與接納自己]可看到:
什麼是自我形象?
是一個人對自己的看法。
別人對自己的看法比較重要還是自己對自己的看法比較重要? 當然是自己啦!
然而,別人對你的看法和自己看自己的看法有些時候是有很大的差距。
例如美國影星伊麗莎白泰勒在螢幕上是何等美麗,但她自己卻說她不喜歡自己的長相、聲音太粗,手掌太大、等等。大家也知道她離過幾次婚。不健康的自我形象會拆毀一個人的生命。
自我形象是如何造成的?
在幼小的時候,你周圍的親人對你的看法會直接影響你的看法。一個孩子是透過周圍人的眼睛來看他自己。你的父母對你滿意嗎?會拿你跟別人做比較嗎?會常對你表達他們的不滿嗎?那也許會造成你的自卑及情緒上的一些困擾。這讓我們誤以為,我們的價值就等於我們的表現! 所以當我們表現得不好時,我們的價值就會降低了,例如錢賺不夠多、社會地位不夠高、等等。
自我形象錯誤的依據會產生出幾種人:
1)戰勝者:總是把自我肯定建立在戰勝別人上。如果他贏過別人就覺得自己還不錯,如果輸了就覺得自卑。
2)成就者:為自己樹立目標,並將他的自我肯定建立在是否能達到這些目標上。當沒達到時就開始覺得自己很沒價值,或達到後就非常的驕傲。
3)討好者:他以別人的贊同會反對來衡量個人的成敗。換句話說,如果別人覺得他還不錯,他就覺得自己很不錯。可是如果今天老闆對他皺個眉頭,他就覺得自己毫無價值。所以這個人是活在別人對他的反應裡面。他容許別人來掌控他的情緒。
以上幾種人都是容許環境,容許他自己的表現來決定他今天要快樂還自卑。我們可以看到以上些人都活在不安裡面,因為他們對自己的肯定和接納是建立在這種外在的環境裡面。我們根據這些錯誤的價值觀,有可能真正的愛與接納我們自己嗎?常常我們發現最大的敵人是我們自己,別人並沒有說我們不好,我們自己卻在心裡面不斷地否定自己。即使神留一些缺點在我們身上,也是要我們透過這些缺陷來經驗到祂的大能。
魅力三大原則 (馮志梅[魅力其實很簡單])
1)肯定自我:清楚的知道自己生命的價值,不需要透過壓倒/拆毀別人來自我肯定。自己的情緒也不該因別人的反應起起伏伏,而是深知自己已經盡全力做到該做的,而且沒有對不起自己的良心。
2)主動去愛:跟別人的交流不是注重在如何讓別人喜歡你,而是幫助別人能夠喜歡他們自己,用正面的眼光去看他人,具有建設性的建造他人又不虛假。
3)身懷使命: 擁有遠大的理想,為一個比自己更大更重要的目標而活,不是為自己的幸福、利益,而是為廣大的人群他們的幸福與利益。如果人生只為賺一口飯吃,就太可惜了!拿到學歷將來找個好工作、買棟房子、買部車子、嫁或娶一個好配偶、生一堆好小孩,然後年老的時候一起去環遊世界,就是這樣以自我為中心,談不上什麼理想。其實不需要換工作,但須在自己的工作裏面找到那個使命感,才能在這個過程當中真正感受到生命的意義和自己的價值。
所以,我們也要學習尊榮文化。跟別人的交流不是注重在如何讓別人喜歡你,而是幫助別人能夠喜歡他們自己,用正面的眼光去看他人,具有建設性的建造他人又不虛假。每個人都是按著神的形象所造的。尊敬人就是尊敬神,而且每個人都希望被尊敬。每個人長處都不同,所以絕對不要因為別人在某一方面做的沒有你好就輕看他。尊榮文化,是用神的眼光看待自己及他人。
那麼,難題來了:我們如何跟與自己意見不同的人溝通又仍然尊敬對方? 劉三牧師在他的文章[反對一個人的言論,不代表討厭他]提到1)我們很容易把「人跟事」綁在一起。2) 我們常常把「意見」跟「感受」混為一談。
例如:
1)功課不好,只是一件事,原因很多;但是有多少父母師長直接去找出這些原因再加以解決?多半是直接得到一個偉大的結論;叫作「你這個笨蛋」。
2)當二個人為了一件「重要的事」產生堅持的時候,幾乎都以「臉紅脖子粗」收場,甚至從此撕破臉,因為;事後證明「輸」的一方從此很難抬頭,「贏」的一方往往雞犬升天,但是;真的有輸贏嗎?冷靜想想;其實沒有,傷了和氣只是因為我們一直習慣「不把『觀念』跟『感覺』分開」,反對他,就嗆他,我們好像沒有考慮過「反對他的意見,不是討厭他」。其實各持己見很正常,沒有人規定「溝通完就一定有共識」。
聖經說「耶穌恨惡罪,卻愛罪人」,就是一個把「人與事分離」的漂亮例子。
另外,多元思考也未必是壞事。聖經是真理,但是每個「個人」從中體會與解釋的「不見得」是絕對的真理,所以聖經才說要「分辨」,所以;我們不會只需要一種聲音,這也是教會歷史精彩之處。所以;把「意見」跟「情緒」分開,不但重要,甚至「必要」。我們每個人都有權力反對另一種主張跟觀點,而且講的時候不討厭他。
我們每個都是神獨一無二的創造。神把妳放在這個角落,賦予你一個使命,你並不是茫茫人海中的一點而已。在你身邊的這些人,也只有你能影響他們:今天有沒有人因為跟你在一起生命更加豐富了呢?有沒有人因為你而跌倒受傷了呢?
Thursday, 29 November 2001
capital punishment and physician involvement in capital punishment
The
issues of capital punishment and physician involvement in capital punishment
have long raised much ethical debate. This essay reviews the arguments in the
context of utilitarian and deontological
ethical theories and the medical ethical principles of non-maleficence, beneficence
and autonomy.
Utilitarianism
is the ethical theory which asserts that no action is intrinsically wrong, but
that the right action to be taken in any given instance is that action with the
best consequences for the majority of individuals. Act utilitarianism proposes
that an act may be ethically justifiable if it has at least as good a
consequence as any other course of action available, while rule utilitarianism
suggests that all individuals should act in accordance with general rules
which, if followed by everyone, would produce the greatest good.
Presumably,
the state could assert that the benefit of capital punishment is solely to
prevent criminals from further harming the public. Act utilitarians would
refute this claim, as the benefit could be achieved less controversially by
providing life imprisonment without parole. Rule utilitarians would also
dispute the ethical reasoning behind this idea, as it would break a common rule,
do not kill. If no-one were to murder anybody else, this would provide the
greatest benefit to the greatest number of people. In the rare case of
execution, the murder of an individual, which would break the rule, would not
provide a strong enough reason to change the rule for all cases. Thus, on the
grounds that the execution of a criminal would prevent this criminal from further
harming the public, both the act and
rule utilitarian would have to oppose capital punishment on ethical
grounds.
Act
and rule utilitarians would be faced with the same arguments if the state were
to assert that the execution of it’s prisoners was ethically justified as it
acted as a deterrent to crime. It cannot be disputed that an effective
deterrent to crime would result in the best consequences for all members of the
state. However, there is currently no evidence that capital punishment in
itself deters other potential criminals (1), thereby eliminating the basis for
act utilitarian ethical justification, as the action does not result in the
best consequences for the majority of individuals.
Rule
utilitarians would again have to consider the rule, do not kill. While the
benefit to society would theoretically be great if an effective deterrent were
found, the evidence does not support this. Regardless, if capital punishment
were found to be an effective deterrent in the future, the benefit in itself
does not provide a compelling enough argument to completely disregard the rule.
Therefore, regardless of the benefits that may be suggested by the state, both
act and rule utilitarianism, from current evidence, would reject any ethical
justification for capital punishment.
The
ethical theory of deontology maintains that an individual will be acting in an
ethical manner if they adhere to the rules and obligations placed upon them by
their societal role or by their profession. Rights-based deontology argues that
an individual who is competent and autonomous has an inherent right not to have
that autonomy infringed. Duty-based deontology would argue the inherent wrong
in defying certain rules and obligations imposed either by the society or the
profession of the individual.
In the
case of capital punishment, a rights based deontologist would acknowledge the
infringement of autonomy perpetrated by the criminal in question, but would not
be able to ethically justify a similar transgression by the state in the name
of punishment. The emphasis here is on the autonomy that another individual
intrinsically holds, which, in no circumstance, can be breached by others. The
duty based deontologists would hold utmost their obligation to society to
refrain from involving themselves in any manner with the death of another human
being. The basic rule or obligation not to kill another would remain paramount.
Hence, for both rights-based and duty-based deontology, the basic nature of the
death penalty, that of killing an individual, can not be reconciled and would
be ethically opposed.
The
issue of the ethical basis of capital punishment is further complicated when
one attempts to justify the involvement of physicians in the practice. To
examine the ethics of physician involvement, the framework by which the actions
of medical professionals are judged must be considered. The four ethical
principles which are regarded central to the practice of medicine, outlined by Beauchamp and Childress
(2), are that of non-maleficence, beneficence, autonomy and justice. These
principles represent a compromise between the major ethical theories of
utilitarianism and deontology. In this discussion, the former three principles
will be addressed; the latter will not be dealt with, merely for the benefit of
brevity. It will be shown that each of
these principles oppose physician involvement in capital punishment.
A
major argument that is raised against physician participation in capital
punishment is the Hippocratic dictum primum non nocere - first do no harm. The
utilitarian would only support non-maleficence if this would result in the best
outcome for the greatest number of people. It is submitted that the act
utilitarian would adhere to this principle for two reasons. Firstly, a doctor
who does no harm to their patients provides a good outcome for the patients. However,
a lack of physical harm does not equate with overall good, so an act
utilitarian may not consider this a reasonable enough explanation to accept the
first do no harm dictum. If the act utilitarian were to consider the outcome if
the principle of non-maleficence were broken, a different picture emerges.
Where the physician does harm to their patients, it is not only physical; the
trust in the physician and the profession is also damaged. This disadvantages
the greatest number of people. For this reason, the act utilitarian would
support the concept of first do no harm. The rule utilitarian would support the
existence of a rule in accordance with non-maleficence and take this at face value. Under both systems of
utilitarianism, the principle of non-maleficence is justified.
Both
rights and duty based theories of deontology support the medical ethical
principle of non-maleficence. A rights-based deontologist would argue that if
the physician were to break the Hippocratic dictum and proceed to harm his
patient, he would infringe upon the patients autonomy and thus behave in an
ethically unacceptable manner. A duty-based theorist would suggest that the professional
obligation of the physician to do no harm, constitutes an duty strong enough
that, if violated, amounts to unethical behavior. The duty here is held
paramount. Thus, both interpretations of deontological theory lend credibility
to the medical principle of non-maleficence.
While
the binding nature of the principle of non-maleficence is assumed, it is
contended that this is not equal to a ban on physician participation in
executions. Some argue "that an execution itself may not be a harm, that
participation by a doctor does not cause harm to the condemned but is in his
interests and that the doctor may owe a duty to society, that is morally more
important than the principle of ‘do no harm’ (3, page 135).
Some
may consider that death is not always harmful. Execution by its nature as a
punishment must constitute harm. In contrast, cases where a patient is
afflicted with immense suffering as the result of a terminal disease, a doctor
who aids in their death is seen to ultimately be preventing harm by allowing a
dignified death. In such cases, death is the least harmful of all possible
consequences. Any assistance given by a physician is merely as an adherence to the
principle of patient autonomy. Physicians cannot use the same reasoning with
respect to an execution, as death is clearly not a lesser harm. If we reason
that the execution should not be seen as a murder, but as a punishment, and
thus not constituting harm, we encounter a simple problem of definition;
punishment by it’s nature is "the loss or suffering inflicted in the name
of discipline (4, page 871)". Unlike the suffering of a terminally ill
patient an execution, where there is no previous significant harm or suffering
of the condemned, death can only result in the greatest harm. Therefore, the
execution of a criminal can be regarded as harmful to that individual and
physician participation in such an act is prohibited by the medical ethical
principle - first do no harm.
Beneficence
is the ethical principle which asserts that one should seek to benefit others
by preventing harm and promoting good (5, page 283). In the case of
beneficence, the act utilitarian cannot argue that the absence of harm does not
necessarily constitute the greatest good; the basis of beneficence is not only
to prevent harm but also to promote good. If all physicians, were acting in
accordance with this principle, it is obvious that the greatest good would
eventuate for everyone, thus the principle must be supported. Again, the
rule-based utilitarian could not deny that a rule, where harm is prevented and
good is promoted, if followed by all physicians, would lead to the greatest
good for the greatest number of individuals, fulfilling their criteria for
ethical justification. Hence, both act and rule utilitarians would support the
principle of beneficence.
The
two understandings of deontological theory allow ethical justification of the
principle of beneficence. The rights-based deontologist states that an
individual has an intrinsic right to be prevented from any harm which would
encroach on their autonomy, and at the same time is entitled to benefits which
promote their autonomy, thus supporting the principle of beneficence. The
duty-based deontologist would regard the societal role of the physician as
‘healer’ as an ethical obligation unto itself. The physician is bound not only
by their professional ethics but by their duty to society to promote good. Thus,
beneficence as a medical ethical principle is justified by the theory of
deontology.
In the
context of capital punishment, some suggest that physician participation benefits
the condemned. These individuals argue that "physicians have a
responsibility to ensure the patient receives proper care and a quick and
merciful death. [They maintain] that if a life must be taken, it should be done
in the most humane way possible" (6, page 18). Therefore, physician
participation is seen as a compassionate act. In support of their arguments, many
articles (3,7) cite examples where, due to a lack of medical expertise, the first
attempt is aborted, necessitating painful ‘ second attempts’ to ensure that the
execution is successful. This pain, say advocates, is not in the best interests
of the patient and can be prevented by physician involvement. Sikora and
Fleischmann (8) suggest that because physicians possess the technical skills to
provide a less painful death, it cannot then automatically be assumed an
ethical pursuit. It is submitted that these skills could be acquired by
individuals who are not physicians, thus eliminating the basis of ethical debate. In any case, the infliction
of direct harm or mutilation of healthy persons without medical benefit,
regardless of intent and societal goals, is not part of the ethical practice of
medicine and should not be condoned by the medical practitioner (9).
The
ethical dilemma of physician involvement in capital punishment is further
complicated by the situation where the condemned individual requests such
participation. This introduces the principle of autonomy, which states that a
physician should respect the decisions of individuals, given that these
decisions do not infringe on the autonomy of others. Ridley (5) asserts that
the two forms of utilitarianism clearly require that autonomy be respected. The
basis of utilitarian theory rests with the consequences of certain actions,
whether this is determined on a case-by-case basis or by following certain
rules. In either case, an action whose consequence results in the greatest good
for the greatest number of people is considered ethically justifiable. To
achieve this, the individual performing the action must have some idea of what
will be considered the best consequences. No-one is more qualified to decide
what an individual will consider the best consequences than the individual
themselves. This being the case, any utilitarian theory must accept the
principle of autonomy.
Deontology
supports the ethical principle of autonomy in both interpretations of it’s
theory. Rights-based theory supports the principle as it constitutes the basis
of the theory. In the medical setting, the rights-based theorist would suggest
that the doctor must support any decision the patient makes, providing that the
decision does not prevent the doctor from acting autonomously. The patient
cannot call on their right to autonomy to force the doctor to participate in
something to which they are opposed. The duty-based deontologist gives ethical
justification to the societal obligation to allow an individual to decide the
outcome of their own lives. Therefore, deontological theory supports the
medical ethical principle of autonomy.
A
condemned individual’s request for physician involvement in their execution
often draws analogies with the request made of the physician to assist in
euthanasia. The nature of death facing a patient on death-row cannot be
regarded as one that they can choose with their own free will. Most criminals
would aim to avoid death by execution by whatever means possible. Therefore, the
physician cannot accept the patient’s right to autonomy as justification for
participation. Regardless, the patients request, if fulfilled by the physician,
may infringe on the physician’s right to decide not to participate. While some argue
that physician participation in an execution can be ethically justified by
appealing to the condemned’s right to autonomy, this argument ignores the
coercive nature in which this request is inevitably made.
In
conclusion, it has been demonstrated that utilitarianism and deontology, the
two major ethical theories, do not support capital punishment. Likewise, the
medical ethical principles of non-maleficence, beneficence and autonomy, which
are born of a compromise between these ethical theories, lend no justification
to physician involvement in capital punishment. It follows that capital
punishment can never be ethically justified, and that physician involvement in
such a practice undermines the moral foundations of the medical profession, by
breaching the fundamental principles which govern the practice of medicine.
REFERENCE LIST
1. Radelet, M., Akers, R.L. Deterrence and
the death penalty: the view of experts. J.
Criminal Law Criminol. 1996; 87,
1-16.
2. Beauchamp, T.L. and Childress, J.F.
Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.
3. Michalos, C. Medical ethics and the
executing process in the United States of America. Med. Law. 1997; 16:
125-167.
4. Moore, B. (ed.) The Australian Pocket
Oxford Dictionary. 4th Edition. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1996.
5. Ridley, A. Beginning bioethics. A text
with integrated readings. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1998.
6. Committee on Bioethical Issues of the
Medical Society of the State of New York. Physician involvement in capital
punishment. NY State J. Med. 1991; 91: 15-18.
7. Ragon, S.A. A doctor’s dilema:
resolving the conflict between physician participation in executions and the
AMA’s code of medical ethics. University
of Dayton Law Review. 1995; 20:
975-1007.
8. Sikora, A. and Fleischman, A.R.
Physician participation in capital punishment: a question of professional
integrity. J. Urban Health. 1999; 76, 400-408.
9. Council on Scientific Affairs, American
Medical Association. Female genital mutilation. JAMA. 1995; 274:
1714-1716.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)